In doubt
1. A dark comet
Comets get a push from gas escaping as their ice warms. A "dark comet" would do the same thing without any visible tail. In 2023, astronomers found 1998 KY26 being nudged in a way that ordinary sunlight and heat couldn't easily explain, and suggested it might be one.
Evidence for
- Its push is larger than the usual sunlight-and-heat effects normally produce (Seligman et al., 2023)
- Early studies compared its colour and radar echo to water-bearing meteorites (JPL, 1999)
Evidence against
- Its coldest areas still average about −61 °C, too warm for ice to survive long (Hansen & Hirabayashi, 2026)
- Ice powering the push would be gone in about 62 years, a blink for an object likely billions of years old
- No gas or dust has ever been seen coming off it
Still open
- No one knows how long it has been in its current orbit, which affects whether ice could remain
- Hayabusa2 could look for ice or venting directly in 2031
Back in contention
2. Sunlight and heat
Sunlight carries a tiny push, and a rock that soaks up heat and radiates it back out gets a slight recoil. On something as small and light as an 11 m rock, these effects add up. If ice is ruled out, this becomes the most conventional explanation.
Evidence for
- Earlier research found sunlight and escaping heat could produce the extra push without any water (FOX 9)
- Its reflected light matches a rocky asteroid from the inner asteroid belt (Astronomy & Astrophysics, 2026)
- It's very bright and small, so sunlight has an outsized effect
Evidence against
- The 2023 analysis found the push was stronger than these effects typically produce, and in a direction they can't easily explain (Seligman et al., 2023)
Still open
- Its exact shape, mass and density, which decide how strongly sunlight moves it
- Hayabusa2 can measure all three up close
Long shot
3. A lost Soviet spacecraft
Phobos 1 was a Soviet probe launched toward Mars on 7 July 1988 and lost two months later after a faulty command. A team including Harvard astrophysicist Avi Loeb argues that 1998 KY26 could be that probe, pushed around by sunlight on its large solar panels.
Evidence for
- A simple model of the spinning probe matched eight sets of brightness observations (FOX 9)
- A model of sunlight pushing on flat panels fit hundreds of telescope and radar measurements better
- The authors say the two orbits are similar, and the difference between them was within the probe's thruster capacity (arXiv)
Evidence against
- Both papers are preprints, not yet peer-reviewed, and the authors call the case unproven
- NASA's administrator says he's seen no evidence it's anything but an asteroid
- Separate studies find its light consistent with ordinary rock
Still open
- A close-up image in 2031 would settle this one immediately